Finance Minster, Pravin Gordhan, has warned that South Africa would face a dark economic future if the interdict temporarily halting the e-toll project wasn’t set aside urgently. We’d have to brace ourselves for negative international credit ratings. And essential services to schools, hospitals and roads would also be adversely affected, he said.
A current High Court order prevents the SA National Roads Agency (Sanral) from levying or collecting e-tolls pending the outcome of a judicial review.
Business Day reported earlier:
The North Gauteng High Court’s decision to interdict e-tolling on Gauteng’s highways constitutes unlawful interference by the judiciary in the affairs of the government, Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan, the South African National Roads Agency (Sanral) and government departments argue in their appeal against the decision.
In an unusual move, Mr Gordhan and his colleagues have approached the Constitutional Court directly, rather than lodging the appeal with the High Court.
In an affidavit lodged with the application, Mr Gordhan says at the heart of the dispute “lies a fundamental issue regarding the separation of powers and whether or not a court can exercise discretionary judgment over a government policy decision”.
If left unchecked, the e-tolling judgment could set “a precedent for future judicial intervention along similar lines”.
Mr Gordhan said it was therefore imperative that the Constitutional Court considered the matter to “determine the limits of this kind of judicial intervention”.
Judge Bill Prinsloo’s judgment, handed down on April 28, favoured an application brought by the Opposition to Urban Tolling Alliance (Outa) and interdicted Sanral from commencing tolling on Gauteng’s highways prior to a full judicial review of the project.
But Mr Gordhan argued the interdict was a judgment of “long-lasting consequence” because the review would take at least a year as the litigation went through the courts. Meanwhile, the delay would cause irreparable harm to the government and the country.
Not only would the government be prevented from collecting revenue that it was empowered by law to collect to meet its debt and other financial obligations, but the harm would extend to the financial standing and reputation of the government, Mr Gordhan said.
“This cannot be allowed to continue and in these circumstances, the applicants are constrained to apply to this court for leave to appeal against the judgment.”
That the courts had “unlawfully” strayed into the terrain of the executive was made all the more serious by the fact that the decisions around e-tolling were based on rational policies and were longstanding, Mr Gordhan argued. Fiscal policy decisions, in particular, were “sensitive” and were decisions that could only be made by the government.”
Opposition to Urban Tolling Alliance spokesman, Wayne Duvenhage, relayed their position on the latest developments:
We can confirm that we received affidavits for the Constitutional Court, and we are currently looking at them. Their [government's] argument is based around its right to introduce policy that it deems appropriate.
If they can’t do that, then they say it could damage the country’s economy. We are arguing that it is not the court interdict that is the issue, it is about the poor decisions around e-tolling. Government cannot introduce policies that are oppressive on the country’s people. Policies need to be reasonable.
Essentially, it’s about judicial intervention and Gordhan said it’s imperative that the Constitutional Court considered the matter to “determine the limits of this kind of judicial intervention.”
What is it about the internet that brings out the worst in people? Look, I get that you ca...
Seeing as though our democracy turned 21 this year (and could theoretically gamble and dri...
In a country full of miserable ginger haggis-eaters I imagine the title of 'Scotland's hap...
Hey you, yes you, over there in the corner licking your fingers clean of that chocolate yo...
It is no secret I rave on and on about coconut water, and most specifically Cocofina. I pr...